Use this rent vs buy calculator to compare wealth, not just the monthly payment. The buyer puts cash into a house. The renter invests that same cash. Each month, whoever pays less invests the difference. At the end, the house is sold and the selling cost comes off.
Rent vs Buy Calculator
Appreciation, rent growth, and the investment return are inputs you choose. They are not a forecast.
Results
A negative advantage means renting finishes with more wealth under these inputs.
The formula
Down payment and closing costs are cash at the start. The loan is price minus down payment. Principal and interest use the standard mortgage payment. Monthly owning cost adds property tax, insurance, maintenance, and HOA. Tax, insurance, and maintenance stay flat. Rent steps up once a year by the growth rate.
The renter starts with the down payment plus closing costs, invested at your return, compounded monthly. Each month the side with the lower housing cost invests the difference at that same return. After the horizon, home value = price x (1 + appreciation)^years. Sale proceeds = value x (1 – selling cost) – the remaining loan balance. Buyer wealth is sale proceeds plus the buyer’s side investments.
The payment alone is on the mortgage calculator. A later rate change is on the refinance break-even calculator.
Questions
What does the comparison actually measure?
Wealth at the end of the horizon. The buyer has home equity after selling costs, plus any monthly surplus they invested. The renter has the cash the buyer put down, grown at the return you type, plus any months where rent was cheaper than owning.
Does the house payment include tax and maintenance?
Yes. The monthly owning cost is principal and interest, plus property tax, insurance, maintenance, and HOA. Tax, insurance, and maintenance stay flat. Only the home's value and the rent grow.
Why does buying sometimes lose even if the payment is close to rent?
The down payment and closing costs are invested by the renter from day one, and selling costs come off the home value. A short horizon often favors renting for that reason, even when the monthly numbers look similar.
Are the growth rates predictions?
No. Appreciation, rent growth, and the investment return are inputs you choose. Change them before you treat the winner as a fact.